*Access to
publishers only.

Directory
information for TPA member newspapers may be found under "Newspapers
Online" or by calling to order your copy of the Tennessee Newspaper
Directory today. ($40 cover price waived for members and clients.) |
Tennessee
Public Meetings Law (Sunshine Law)
view text download
PDF version
Tennessee
Public Records Law
view text download
PDF version
Tennessee
Shield Law
view text download
PDF version
Sunshine Law case tried
by jury, Knox County Commission found guilty of violating Tennessee Open
Meetings Law
Read about the News Sentinel vs. Knox County Commission
case, from the January 31, 2007 Knox County Commission meeting through
the October 5, 2007 nullifcation of Commission appointments in the case
study special section of the January 2008 edition of The Tennessee
Press.
Resources:
Tennessee
Office of Open Records Ombudsman http://comptroller.state.tn.us/openrecords/index.htm
TPA
Legal Hotline (a service for TPA member newspapers only)
TPA Government
Affairs Committee
Elizabeth Blackstone, Chairman, Kennedy Newspapers, Columbia
Michael Williams, Co-chairman, The Paris Post-Intelligencer;
Frank Gibson, TPA FOI Coordinator, Tennessee Coalition for Open Government
Greg Sherrill, TPA Executive Director
Tennessee
Coalition for Open Government www.tcog.info
First Amendment
Center http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/
Sunshine
Week www.sunshineweek.org
National Freedom
of Information Coalition http://www.nfoic.org/
STATE OF TENNESSEE PUBLIC
RECORDS LAW
T.C.A. § 10-7-503 - 505
10-7-503. Records open to public inspection — Exceptions.
— (a) All state, county and municipal records and all records maintained
by the Tennessee performing arts center management corporation, except
any public documents authorized to be destroyed by the county public records
commission in accordance with § 10-7-404, shall at all times, during
business hours, be open for personal inspection by any citizen of Tennessee,
and those in charge of such records shall not refuse such right of inspection
to any citizen,unless otherwise provided by state law.
(b) The head of a governmental entity may promulgate rules in accordance
with the Uniform Administrative Procedures Act, compiled in title 4, chapter
5, to maintain the confidentiality of records concerning adoption proceedings
or records required to be kept confidential by federal statute or regulation
as a condition for the receipt of federal funds or for participation in
a federally funded program.
(c)(1) Except as provided in § 10-7-504(g), all law enforcement personnel
records shall be open for inspection as provided in subsection (a); however,
whenever the personnel records of a law enforcement officer are inspected
as provided in subsection (a), the custodian shall make a record of such
inspection and provide notice, within three (3) days from the date of
the inspection, to the officer whose personnel records have been inspected:
(A) That such inspection has taken place;
(B) The name, address and telephone number of the person making such inspection;
(C) For whom the inspection was made; and
(D) The date of such inspection.
(2) Any person making an inspection of such records shall provide such
person’s name, address, business telephone number, home telephone
number, driver license number or other appropriate identification prior
to inspecting such records.
(d)(1) All records of any association or nonprofit corporation described
in § 8-44 102(b)(1)(E)(i) shall be open for inspection as provided
in subsection (a); provided, that any such organization shall not be subject
to the requirements of this subsection so long as it complies with the
following requirements:
(A) The board of directors of the organization shall cause an annual audit
to be made of the financial affairs of the organization, including all
receipts from every source and every expenditure or disbursement of the
money of the organization, made by a disinterested person skilled in such
work. Each audit shall cover the period extending back to the date of
the last preceding audit and it shall be paid out of the funds of the
organization;
(B) Each audit shall be conducted in accordance with the standards established
by the comptroller of the treasury pursuant to § 4-3-304(9) for local
governments;
(C) The comptroller of the treasury, through the department of audit,
shall be responsible for ensuring that the audits are prepared in accordance
with generally accepted governmental auditing standards, and determining
whether the audits meet minimum audit standards which shall be prescribed
by the comptroller of the treasury. No audit may be accepted as meeting
the requirements of this section until such audit has been approved by
the comptroller of the treasury;
(D) The audits may be prepared by a certified public accountant, a public
accountant or by the department of audit. If the governing body of the
municipality fails or refuses to have the audit prepared, the comptroller
of the treasury may appoint a certified public accountant or public accountant
or direct the department to prepare the audit. The cost of such audit
shall be paid by the organization;
(E) Each such audit shall be completed as soon as practicable after the
end of the fiscal year of the organization. One (1) copy of each audit
shall be furnished to the organization and one (1) copy shall be filed
with the comptroller of the treasury. The copy of the comptroller of the
treasury shall be available for public inspection. Copies of each audit
shall also be made available to the press; and
(F) In addition to any other information required by the comptroller of
the treasury, each audit shall also contain:
(i) A listing, by name of the recipient, of all compensation, fees or
other remuneration paid by the organization during the audit year to,
or accrued on behalf of, the organization’s directors and officers;
(ii) A listing, by name of recipient, of all compensation and any other
remuneration paid by the organization during the audit year to, or accrued
on behalf of, any employee of the organization who receives more than
twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) in remuneration for such year;
(iii) A listing, by name of beneficiary, of any deferred compensation,
salary continuation, retirement or other fringe benefit plan or program
(excluding qualified health and life insurance plans available to all
employees of the organization on a nondiscriminatory basis) established
or maintained by the organization for the benefit of any of the organization’s
directors, officers or employees, and the amount of any funds paid or
accrued to such plan or program during the audit year; and
(iv) A listing, by name of recipient, of all fees paid by the organization
during the audit year to any contractor, professional advisor or other
personal services provider, which exceeds two thousand five hundred dollars
($2,500) for such year. Such listing shall also include a statement as
to the general effect of each contract, but not the amount paid or payable
thereunder.
The provisions of this subsection shall not apply to any association or
nonprofit corporation described in § 8-44-102(b)(1)(E)(i), that employs
no more than two (2) full-time staff members.
(2) The provisions of this subsection (d) shall not apply to any association,
organization or corporation that was exempt from federal income taxation
under the provisions of § 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code
(26 U.S.C. § 501(c)(3)) as of January 1, 1998, and which makes available
to the public its federal return of organization exempt from income tax
(Form 990) in accordance with the Internal Revenue Code and related regulations.
[Acts 1957, ch. 285, § 1; T.C.A., § 15-304; Acts 1981, ch. 376,
§ 1; 1984, ch. 929, §§ 1, 3; 1991, ch. 369, § 7; 1993,
ch. 475, § 1; 1998, ch. 1102, §§ 2, 4; 1999, ch. 514, §
1.]
10-7-504. Confidential records. — (a) (1) The medical records of
patients in state, county and municipal hospitals and medical facilities,
and the medical records of persons receiving medical treatment, in whole
or in part, at the expense of the state, county or municipality, shall
be treated as confidential and shall not be open for inspection by members
of the public. Any records containing the source of body parts for transplantation
or any information concerning persons donating body parts for transplantation
shall be treated as confidential and shall not be open for inspection
by members of the public.
(2) All investigative records of the Tennessee bureau of investigation,
all criminal investigative files of the motor vehicle enforcement division
of the department of safety relating to stolen vehicles or parts, and
all files of the handgun carry permit and driver licenseissuance divisions
of the department of safety relating to bogus handgun carry permits and
bogus driver licenses issued to undercover law enforcement agents shall
be treated as confidential and shall not be open to inspection by members
of the public. The information contained in such records shall be disclosed
to the public only in compliance with a subpoena or an order of a court
of record; however, such investigative records of the Tennessee bureau
of investigation shall be open to inspection by elected members of the
general assembly if such inspection is directed by a duly adopted resolution
of either house or of a standing or joint committee of either house. Records
shall not be available to any member of the executive branch except those
directly involved in the investigation in the Tennessee bureau of
investigation itself and the governor. The bureau, upon written request
by an authorized person of a state governmental agency, is authorized
to furnish and disclose to the requesting agency the criminal history,
records and data from its files, and the files of the federal government
and other states to which it may have access, for the limited purpose
of determining whether a license or permit should be issued to any person,
corporation, partnership or other entity, to engage in an authorized activity
affecting the rights, property or interests of the public or segments
thereof.
(3) The records, documents and papers in the possession of the military
department which involve the security of the United States and/or the
state of Tennessee, including, but not restricted to, national guard personnel
records, staff studies and investigations, shall be treated as confidential
and shall not be open for inspection by members of the public.
(4) The records of students in public educational institutions shall be
treated as confidential. Information in such records relating to academic
performance, financial status of a student or the student’s parent
or guardian, medical or psychological treatment or testing shall not bemade
available to unauthorized personnel of the institution or to the public
or any agency, except those agencies authorized by the educational institution
to conduct specific research or otherwise authorized by the governing
board of the institution, without the consent of the student involved
or the parent or guardian of a minor student attending any institution
of elementary or secondary education, except as otherwise provided by
law or regulation pursuant thereto, and except in consequence of due legal
process or in cases when the safety of persons or property is involved.
The governing board of the institution, the department of education, and
the Tennessee higher education commission shall have access on a confidential
basis to such records as are required to fulfill their lawful functions.
Statistical information not identified with a particular student may be
released to any person, agency, or the public; and information relating
only to an individual student’s name, age, address, dates of attendance,
grade levels completed, class placement and academic degrees awarded may
likewise be disclosed.
(5)(A) The following books, records and other materials in the possession
of the office of the attorney general and reporter which relate to any
pending or contemplated legal or administrative proceeding in which the
office of the attorney general and reporter may be involved shall not
be open for public inspection:
(i) Books, records or other materials which are confidential or privileged
by state law;
(ii) Books, records or other materials relating to investigations conducted
by federal law enforcement or federal regulatory agencies, which are confidential
or privileged under federal law;
(iii) The work product of the attorney general and reporter or any attorney
working under the attorney general and reporter’s supervision and
control;
(iv) Communications made to or by the attorney general and reporter or
any attorney working under the attorney general and reporter’s supervision
and control in the context of the attorney-client relationship; or
(v) Books, records and other materials in the possession of other departments
and agencies which are available for public inspection and copying pursuant
to §§ 10-7-503 and 10-7-506. It is the intent of this section
to leave subject to public inspection and copying pursuant to §§
10-7-503 and 10-7 506 such books, records and other materials in the possession
of other departments even though copies of the same books, records and
other materials which are also in the possession of the office of the
attorney general and reporter are not subject to inspection or copying
in the office of the attorney general and reporter; provided, that such
records, books and materials are available for copying and inspection
in such other departments.
(B) Books, records and other materials made confidential by this subsection
which are in the possession of the office of the attorney general and
reporter shall be open to inspection by the elected members of the general
assembly, if such inspection is directed by a duly adopted resolution
of either house or of a standing or joint committee of either house and
is required for the conduct of legislative business.
(C) Except for the provisions of subdivision (a)(5)(B), the books, records
and materials made confidential or privileged by this subdivision shall
be disclosed to the public only in the discharge of the duties of the
office of the attorney general and reporter.
(6) State agency records containing opinions of value of real and personal
property intended to be acquired for a public purpose shall not be open
for public inspection until the acquisition thereof has been finalized.
This shall not prohibit any party to a condemnation action from making
discovery relative to values pursuant to the Rules of Civil Procedure
as prescribed by law.
(7) Proposals received pursuant to personal service, professional service,
and consultant service contract regulations, and related records, including
evaluations and memoranda, shall be available for public inspection only
after the completion of evaluation of same by the state. Sealed bids for
the purchase of goods and services, and leases of real property, and individual
purchase records, including evaluations and memoranda relating to same,
shall be available for public inspection only after the completion of
evaluation of same by the state.
(8) All investigative records and reports of the internal affairs division
of the department of correction or of the department of children’s
services shall be treated as confidential and shall not be open to inspection
by members of the public. However, an employee of the department of correction
or of the department of children’s services shall be allowed to
inspect such investigative records and reports if the records or reports
form the basis of an adverse action against the employee. The release
of reports and records shall be in accordance with the Tennessee Rules
of Civil Procedure. The court or administrative judge having jurisdiction
over the proceedings shall issue appropriate protective orders, when necessary,
to ensure that the information is disclosed only to appropriate persons.
The information contained in such records and reports shall be disclosed
to the public only in compliance with a subpoena or an order of a court
of record.
(9) Official health certificates, collected and maintained by the state
veterinarian pursuant to rule chapter 0080-2-1 of the department of agriculture,
shall be treated as confidential and shall not be open for inspection
by members of the public.
(10)(A) The capital plans, marketing information, proprietary information
and trade secrets submitted to the Tennessee venture capital network at
Middle Tennessee State University shall be treated as confidential and
shall not be open for inspection by members of the public.
(B) As used in this subdivision (a)(10), unless the context otherwise
requires:
(i) “Capital plans” means plans, feasibility studies, and
similar research and information that will contribute to the identification
of future business sites and capital investments;
(ii) “Marketing information” means marketing studies, marketing
analyses, and similar research and information designed to identify potential
customers and business relationships;
(iii) “Proprietary information” means commercial or financial
information which is used either directly or indirectly in the business
of any person or company submitting information to the Tennessee venture
capital network at Middle Tennessee State University, and which gives
such person an advantage or an opportunity to obtain an advantage over
competitors who do not know or use such information;
(iv) “Trade secrets” means manufacturing processes, materials
used therein, and costs associated with the manufacturing process of a
person or company submitting information to the Tennessee venture capital
network at Middle Tennessee State University.
(11) Records that are of historical research value which are given or
sold to public archival institutions, public libraries, or libraries of
a unit of the Tennessee board of regents or the
University of Tennessee, when the owner or donor of such records wishes
to place restrictions on access to the records shall be treated as confidential
and shall not be open for inspection by members of the public. This exemption
shall not apply to any records prepared or received in the course of the
operation of state or local governments;
(12) Personal information contained in motor vehicle records shall be
treated as confidential and shall only be open for inspection in accordance
with the provisions of title 55, chapter 25.
(13)(A) All memoranda, work notes or products, case files and communications
related to mental health intervention techniques conducted by mental health
professionals in a group setting to provide job-related critical incident
counseling and therapy to law enforcement officers, emergency medical
technicians, emergency medical technician-paramedics, and firefighters,
both volunteer and professional, are confidential and privileged and are
not subject to disclosure in any judicial or administrative proceeding
unless all parties waive such privilege. In order for such privilege to
apply, the incident counseling and/or therapy shall be conducted by a
qualified mental health professional as defined in § 33-10-301;
(B) For the purposes of this section, “group setting” means
that more than one (1) person is present with the mental health professional
when the incident counseling and/or therapy is being conducted;
(C) All memoranda, work notes or products, case files and communications
pursuant to this section shall not be construed to be public records pursuant
to title 10, chapter 7;
(D) Nothing in this section shall be construed as limiting a licensed
professional’s obligation to report suspected child abuse or limiting
such professional’s duty to warn about dangerous individuals as
provided under title 33, chapter 10, part 3, or other provisions relevant
to the mental health professional’s license;
(E) Nothing in this section shall be construed as limiting the ability
of a patient or client, or such person’s survivor, to discover under
the Rules of Civil Procedure or to admit in evidence under the Rules of
Evidence any memoranda, work notes or products, case files and communications
which are privileged by this section and which are relevant to a malpractice
action or any other action by a patient against a mental health professional
arising out of the professional relationship. In such an action against
a mental health professional, neither shall anything in this section be
construed as limiting the ability of the mental health professional to
so discover or admit in evidence such memoranda, work notes or products,
case files and communications.
(14) All riot, escape and emergency transport plans which are incorporated
in a policy and procedures manual of county jails and workhouses or prisons
operated by the department of correction or under private contract shall
be treated as confidential and shall not be open for inspection by members
of the public.
(15)(A) As used in this subdivision (a)(15), unless the context otherwise
requires:
(i) “Identifying information” means the home and work addresses
and telephone numbers, social security number, and any other information
that could reasonably be used to locate the whereabouts of an individual;
(ii) “Protection document” means:
(a) An order of protection issued pursuant to title 36, chapter 3, part
6, that has been granted after proper notice and an opportunity to be
heard;
(b) A similar order of protection issued by the court of another jurisdiction;
(c) An extension of an ex parte order of protection granted pursuant to
§ 36-3-605(a);
(d) A similar extension of an ex parte order of protection granted by
a court of competent jurisdiction in another jurisdiction;
(e) A restraining order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction prohibiting
violence against the person to whom it is issued;
(f) A court order protecting the confidentiality of certain information
issued upon the request of a district attorney general to a victim or
witness in a criminal case, whether pending or completed; and
(g) An affidavit from the director of a rape crisis center or domestic
violence shelter certifying that an individual is a victim in need of
protection; provided, that such affidavit is on a standardized form to
be developed and distributed to such centers and shelters by the Tennessee
task force against domestic violence; and
(iii) “Utility service provider” means any entity, whether
public or private, that provides electricity, natural gas, water, or telephone
service to customers on a subscription basis, whether or not regulated
by the Tennessee regulatory authority.
(B) If the procedure set out in this subdivision (a)(15) is followed,
identifying information compiled and maintained by a utility service provider
concerning a person who has obtained a valid protection document shall
be treated as confidential and not open for inspection by the public.
(C) For the provisions of subdivision (a)(15)(B) to be applicable, a copy
of the protection document must be presented during regular business hours
by the person to whom it was granted to the records custodian of the utility
service provider whose records such person seeks to make confidential,
and such person must request that all identifying information about such
person be maintained as confidential.
(D) The protection document must at the time of presentation be in full
force and effect. The records custodian may assume that a protection document
is in full force and effect if it is on the proper form and if on its
face it has not expired.
(E) Upon being presented with a valid protection document, the records
custodian shall accept receipt of it and maintain it in a separate file
containing in alphabetical order all protection documents presented to
such records custodian pursuant to this subdivision (a)(15). Nothing in
this subdivision (a)(15) shall be construed as prohibiting a records custodian
from maintaining an electronic file of such protection documents provided
the records custodian retains the original document presented.
(F) Identifying information concerning a person that is maintained as
confidential pursuant to this subdivision (a)(15) shall remain confidential
until the person who requested such confidentiality notifies in person
the records custodian of the appropriate utility service provider that
there is no longer a need for such information to remain confidential.
A records custodian receiving such notification shall remove the protection
document concerning such person from the file maintained pursuant to subdivision
(a)(15)(E), and the identifying information about such person shall be
treated in the same manner as the identifying information concerning any
other customer of the utility. Before removing the protection document
and releasing any identifying information, the records custodian of the
utility service provider shall require that the person requesting release
of the identifying information maintained as confidential produce sufficient
identification to satisfy such custodian that he or she is the same person
as the person to whom the document was originally granted.
(G) After July 1, 1999, if information is requested from a utility service
provider about a person other than the requestor and such request is for
information that is in whole or in part identifying information, the records
custodian of the utility service provider shall check the separate file
containing all protection documents that have been presented to such utility.
If the person about whom information is being requested has presented
a valid protection document to the records custodian in accordance with
the procedure set out in this subdivision (a)(15), and has requested that
identifying information about such person be maintained as confidential,
the records custodian shall redact or refuse to disclose to the requestor
any identifying information about such person.
(H) Nothing in this subdivision (a)(15) shall prevent the district attorney
general and counsel for the defendant from providing to each other in
a pending criminal case, where the constitutional rights of the defendant
require it, information which otherwise would be held confidential under
this subdivision (a)(16).
(16) (A) As used in this subdivision (a)(16), unless the context otherwise
requires:
(i) “Governmental entity” means the state of Tennessee and
any county, municipality, city or other political subdivision of the state
of Tennessee;
(ii) “Identifying information” means the home and work addresses
and telephone numbers, social security number, and any other information
that could reasonably be used to locate the whereabouts of an individual;
(iii) “Protection document” means:
(a) An order of protection issued pursuant to title 36, chapter 3, part
6, that has been granted after proper notice and an opportunity to be
heard;
(b) A similar order of protection issued by the court of another jurisdiction;
(c) An extension of an ex parte order of protection granted pursuant to
§ 36-3-605(a);
(d) A similar extension of an ex parte order of protection granted by
a court of competent jurisdiction in another jurisdiction;
(e) A restraining order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction prohibiting
violence against the person to whom it is issued;
(f) A court order protecting the confidentiality of certain information
issued upon the request of a district attorney general to a victim or
witness in a criminal case, whether pending or completed; and
(g) An affidavit from the director of a rape crisis center or domestic
violence shelter certifying that an individual is a victim in need of
protection; provided, that such affidavit is on a standardized form to
be developed and distributed to such centers and shelters by the Tennessee
task force against domestic violence.
(B) If the procedure set out in this subdivision (a)(16) is followed,
identifying information compiled and maintained by a governmental entity
concerning a person who has obtained a valid protection document may be
treated as confidential and may not be open for inspection by the public.
(C) For the provisions of subdivision (a)(16)(B) to be applicable, a copy
of the protection document must be presented during regular business hours
by the person to whom it was granted to the records custodian of the governmental
entity whose records such person seeks to make confidential, and such
person must request that all identifying information about such person
be maintained as confidential.
(D) The protection document presented must at the time of presentation
be in full force and effect. The records custodian may assume that a protection
document is in full force and effect if it is on the proper form and if
on its face it has not expired.
(E) Upon being presented with a valid protection document, the record
custodian may accept receipt of it. If the records custodian does not
accept receipt of such document, the records custodian shall explain to
the person presenting the document why receipt cannot be accepted and
that the identifying information concerning such person will not be maintained
as confidential. If the records custodian does accept receipt of the protection
document, such records custodian shall maintain it in a separate file
containing in alphabetical order all protection documents presented to
such custodian pursuant to this subdivision (a)(16).
Nothing in this subdivision (a)(16) shall be construed as prohibiting
a records custodian from maintaining an electronic file of such protection
documents; provided, that the custodian retains the original document
presented.
(F) Identifying information concerning a person that is maintained as
confidential pursuant to this subpart shall remain confidential until
the person requesting such confidentiality notifies in person the appropriate
records custodian of the governmental entity that there is no longer a
need for such information to remain confidential. A records custodian
receiving such notification shall remove the protection document concerning
such person from the file maintained pursuant to subdivision (a)(16)(E),
and the identifying information about such person shall be treated in
the same manner as identifying information maintained by the governmental
entity about other persons. Before removing the protection document and
releasing any identifying information, the records custodian of the governmental
entity shall require that the person requesting release of the identifying
information maintained as confidential produce sufficient identification
to satisfy such records custodian that that person is the same person
as the person to whom the document was originally granted.
(G) After July 1, 1999, if:
(i) Information is requested from a governmental entity about a person
other than the person making the request;
(ii) Such request is for information that is in whole or in part identifying
information; and
(iii) The records custodian of the governmental entity to whom the request
was made accepts receipt of protection documents and maintains identifying
information as confidential; then such records custodian shall check the
separate file containing all protection documents that have been presented
to such entity. If the person about whom information is being requested
has presented a valid protection document to the records custodian in
accordance with the procedure set out in this subdivision (a)(16), and
has requested that identifying information about such person be maintained
as confidential, the records custodian shall redact or refuse to disclose
to the requestor any identifying information about such person.
(H) Nothing in this subdivision (a)(16) shall prevent the district attorney
general and counsel for the defendant from providing to each other in
a pending criminal case, where the constitutional rights of the defendant
require it, information which otherwise may be held confidential under
this subdivision (a)(16).
(17) The telephone number, address and any other information which could
be used to locate the whereabouts of a domestic violence shelter or rape
crisis center may be treated as confidential by a governmental entity,
and shall be treated as confidential by a utility service provider as
defined in subdivision (a)(15) upon the director of the shelter or crisis
center giving written notice to the records custodian of the appropriate
entity or utility that such shelter or crisis center desires that such
identifying information be maintained as confidential.
(b) Any record designated “confidential” shall be so treated
by agencies in the maintenance, storage and disposition of such confidential
records. These records shall be destroyed in such a manner that they cannot
be read, interpreted or reconstructed. The destruction shall be in accordance
with an approved records disposition authorization from the public records
commission.
(c) Notwithstanding any provision of the law to the contrary, any confidential
public record in existence more than seventy (70) years shall be open
for public inspection by any person unless disclosure of the record is
specifically prohibited or restricted by federal law or unless the record
is a record of services for a person for mental illness or mental retardation.
The provisions of this section do not apply to a record concerning an
adoption or a record maintained by the office of vital records or by the
Tennessee bureau of investigation. For the purpose of providing an orderly
schedule of availability for access to such confidential public records
for public inspection, all records created and designated as confidential
prior to January 1, 1901, shall be open for public inspection on January
1, 1985. All other public records created and designated as confidential
after January 1, 1901 and which are seventy (70) years old on January
1, 1985, shall be open for public inspection on January 1, 1986; thereafter
all such records shall be open for public inspection pursuant to this
part after
seventy (70) years from the creation date of such records.
(d) Records of any employee’s identity, diagnosis, treatment, or
referral for treatment that are maintained by any state or local government
employee assistance program shall be confidential; provided, that any
such records are maintained separately from personnel and other records
regarding such employee that are open for inspection. For purposes of
this subsection, “employee assistance program” means any program
that provides counseling, problem identification, intervention, assessment,
or referral for appropriate diagnosis and treatment, and follow-up services
to assist employees of such state or local governmental entity who are
impaired by personal concerns including, but not limited to, health, marital,
family, financial, alcohol, drug, legal, emotional, stress or other personal
concerns which may adversely affect employee job performance.
(e) Unpublished telephone numbers in the possession of emergency communications
districts created pursuant to title 7, chapter 86, shall be treated as
confidential and shall not be open for inspection by members of the public
until such time as any provision of the service contract between the telephone
service provider and the consumer providing otherwise is effectuated;
provided, that addresses held with such unpublished telephone numbers,
or addresses otherwise collected or compiled, and in the possession of
emergency communications districts created pursuant to title 7, chapter
86, shall be made available upon written request to any county election
commission for the purpose of compiling a voter mailing list for a respective
county.
(f)(1) The following records or information of any state, county, municipal
or other public employee in the possession of a governmental entity in
its capacity as an employer shall be treated as confidential and shall
not be open for inspection by members of the public: unpublished telephone
numbers; bank account information; social security number; driver license
information except where driving or operating a vehicle is part of the
employee’s job description or job duties or incidental to the performance
of the employee’s job; and the same information of immediate family
members or household members.
(2) Information made confidential by this subsection shall be redacted
wherever possible and nothing in this subsection shall be used to limit
or deny access to otherwise public information because a file, a document,
or data file contains confidential information.
(3) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to limit access to these
records by law enforcement agencies, courts, or other governmental agencies
performing official functions.
(4) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to close any personnel
records of public officers which are currently open under state law.
(5) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to limit access to information
made confidential under this subsection, when the employee expressly authorizes
the release of such information.
(g)(1)(A) Personnel information of any police officer designated as working
undercover may be segregated and maintained in the office of the chief
law enforcement officer. Such segregated information shall be treated
as confidential under this subsection. Such segregated information is
the address and home telephone number of the officer as well as the address
or addresses and home telephone number or numbers of the members of the
officer’s household and/or immediate family. Information in such
file which has the potential, if released, to threaten the safety of the
officer or the officer’s immediate family or household members may
be redacted if the chief law enforcement officer determines that its release
poses such a risk.
(B) If the person requesting the information or the officer disagrees
with the determination of the chief law enforcement officer, the decision
shall be reviewed in a show cause hearing in chancery court.
(2) Nothing in this subsection shall be used to limit or deny access to
otherwise public information because a file, a document, or data file
contains some information made confidential by subdivision (g)(1).
(3) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to limit access to these
records by law enforcement agencies, courts, or other governmental agencies
performing official functions.
(4) Except as provided in subdivision (g)(1), nothing in this subsection
shall be construed to close personnel records of public officers, which
are currently open under state law.
(5) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to limit access to information
made confidential by subdivision (g)(1), when the employee expressly authorizes
the release of such information.
[Acts 1957, ch. 285, § 2; 1970, ch. 531, §§ 1, 2; 1973,
ch. 99, § 1; 1975, ch. 127, § 1; 1976, ch. 552, § 1; 1976,
ch. 777, § 1; 1977, ch. 152, § 3; 1978, ch. 544, § 1; 1978,
ch. 890, § 2; T.C.A., § 15-305; Acts 1983, ch. 211, § 1;
1984, ch. 947, § 2; 1985, ch. 421, §§ 1-4; 1985 (1st E.S.),
ch. 5, § 29; 1987, ch. 118, § 2; 1987, ch. 337, § 20; 1988,
ch. 783, § 1; 1988, ch. 894, § 2; 1989, ch. 75, § 1; 1989,
ch. 278, § 27; 1990, ch. 888, § 1; 1991, ch. 129, § 1;
1992, ch. 823, § 1; 1996, ch. 724, § 1; 1996, ch. 745, §
16; 1996, ch. 1079, § 29; 1997, ch. 84, § 1; 1997, ch. 290,
§ 1; 1997, ch. 292, § 1; 1998, ch. 1075, § 1; 1999, ch.
176, §§ 1, 2; 1999, ch. 199, § 1; 1999, ch. 344, §§
1, 2, 4; 1999, ch. 514, § 2.]
10-7-505. Denial of access - Procedures for obtaining access - Court orders
-
Injunctions - Appeals - Liability for nondisclosure. — (a) Any citizen
of Tennessee who shall request the right of personal inspection of any
state, county or municipal record as provided in § 10-7-503, and
whose request has been in whole or in part denied by the official and/or
designee of the official or through any act or regulation of any official
or designee of any official, shall be entitled to petition for access
to any such record and to obtain judicial review of the actions taken
to deny the access.
(b) Such petition shall be filed in the chancery court for the county
in which the county or municipal records sought are situated, or in any
other court of that county having equity jurisdiction. In the case of
records in the custody and control of any state department, agency or
instrumentality, such petition shall be filed in the chancery court of
Davidson County; or in the chancery court for the county in which the
state records are situated if different from Davidson County, or in any
other court of that county having equity jurisdiction; or in the chancery
court in the county of the petitioner’s residence, or in any other
court of that county having equity jurisdiction. Upon filing of the petition,
the court shall, upon request of the petitioning party, issue an order
requiring the defendant or respondent party or parties to immediately
appear and show cause, if they have any, why the petition should not be
granted.
A formal written response to the petition shall not be required, and the
generally applicable periods of filing such response shall not apply in
the interest of expeditious hearings. The court may direct that the records
being sought be submitted under seal for review by the court and no other
party. The decision of the court on the petition shall constitute a final
judgment on the merits.
(c) The burden of proof for justification of nondisclosure of records
sought shall be upon the official and/or designee of the official of those
records and the justification for the nondisclosure must be shown by a
preponderance of the evidence.
(d) The court, in ruling upon the petition of any party proceeding hereunder,
shall render written findings of fact and conclusions of law and shall
be empowered to exercise full injunctive remedies and relief to secure
the purposes and intentions of this section, and this section shall be
broadly construed so as to give the fullest possible public access to
public records.
(e) Upon a judgment in favor of the petitioner, the court shall order
that the records be made available to the petitioner unless:
(1) There is a timely filing of a notice of appeal; and
(2) The court certifies that there exists a substantial legal issue with
respect to the disclosure of the documents which ought to be resolved
by the appellate courts.
(f) Any public official required to produce records pursuant to this part
shall not be found criminally or civilly liable for the release of such
records, nor shall a public official required to release records in such
public official’s custody or under such public official’s
control be found responsible for any damages caused, directly or indirectly,
by the release of such information.
(g) If the court finds that the governmental entity, or agent thereof,
refusing to disclose a record, knew that such record was public and willfully
refused to disclose it, such court may, in its discretion, assess all
reasonable costs involved in obtaining the record, including reasonable
attorneys’ fees, against the nondisclosing governmental entity.
[Acts 1957, ch. 285, § 3; 1975, ch. 127, § 2; 1977, ch. 152,
§ 4; T.C.A., § 15-306; Acts
1984, ch. 929, §§ 2, 4; 1985, ch. 342, § 1; 1988, ch. 888,
§ 1.]
10-7-507. Records of convictions of traffic and other violations - Availability.—Any
public official having charge or custody of or control over any public
records of convictions of traffic violations or any other state, county
or municipal public offenses shall make available to any citizen, upon
request, during regular office hours, a copy or copies of any such record
requested by such citizen, upon the payment of a reasonable charge or
fee therefor. Such official is authorized to fix a charge or fee per copy
that would reasonably defray the cost of producing and delivering such
copy or copies.
[Acts 1974, ch. 581, § 1; T.C.A., § 15-308.]
Editor’s Note: The Tennessee Supreme Court, applying by inference
Rule 16(a)(2) of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, has held that investigative
files of law enforcement officers involving open matters relevant to pending
or contemplated criminal action are not subject to disclosure and are
not relevant to any pending or contemplated criminal action. Appman v.
Worthington, 746 S.W.2d 165, 166 (Tenn. 1987).
Where investigative records involve students at state colleges or universities,
investigations may also bring privacy assertions under 20 USCA §1232g
also known as the “Buckley Amendment.”
SUNSHINE LAW
T.C.A. § 8-44-101 - 201
CHAPTER 44
PUBLIC MEETINGS
8-44-101. Policy - Construction. — (a) The general assembly hereby
declares it to be the policy of this state that the formation of public
policy and decisions is public business and shall not be conducted in
secret.
(b) This part shall not be construed to limit any of the rights and privileges
contained in article I, § 19 of the Constitution of Tennessee.
[Acts 1974, ch. 442, §§ 1, 8; T.C.A., § 8-4401.]
8-44-102. Open meetings — “Governing body” defined —
“Meeting” defined.— (a) All meetings of any governing
body are declared to be public meetings open to the public at all times,
except as provided by the Constitution of Tennessee.
(b)(1) “Governing body” means:
(A) The members of any public body which consists of two (2) or more members,
with the authority to make decisions for or recommendations to a public
body on policy or administration and also means a community action agency
which administers community action programs under the provisions of 42
U.S.C. § 2790 [repealed]. Any governing body so defined by this section
shall remain so defined, notwithstanding the fact that such governing
body may have designated itself as a negotiation committee for collective
bargaining purposes, and strategy sessions of a governing body under such
circumstances shall be open to the public at all times;
(B) The board of directors of any nonprofit corporation which contracts
with a state agency to receive community grant funds in consideration
for rendering specified services to the public; provided, that community
grant funds comprise at least thirty percent (30%) of the total annual
income of such corporation. Except such meetings of the board of directors
of such nonprofit corporation that are called solely to discuss matters
involving confidential doctor-patient relationships, personnel matters
or matters required to be kept confidential by federal or state law or
by federal or state regulation shall not be covered under the provisions
of this chapter, and no other matter shall be discussed at such meetings;
(C) The board of directors of any not-for-profit corporation authorized
by the laws of Tennessee to act for the benefit or on behalf of any one
(1) or more of counties, cities, towns and local governments pursuant
to the provisions of title 7, chapter 54 or 58. The provisions of this
subdivision (b)(1)(C) shall not apply to any county with a metropolitan
form of government and having a population of four hundred thousand (400,000)
or more according to the 1980 federal census or any subsequent federal
census;
(D) The board of directors of any nonprofit corporation which through
contract or otherwise provides a metropolitan form of government having
a population in excess of five hundred thousand (500,000) according to
the 1990 federal census or any subsequent federal census with heat, steam
or incineration of refuse;
(E) (i) The board of directors of any association or nonprofit corporation
authorized by the laws of Tennessee that:
(a) Was established for the benefit of local government officials or counties,
cities, towns or other local governments or as a municipal bond financing
pool;
(b) Receives dues, service fees or any other income from local government
officials or such local governments that constitute at least thirty percent
(30%) of its total annual income; and
(c) Was authorized as of January 1, 1998, under state law to obtain coverage
for its employees in the Tennessee consolidated retirement system.
(ii) The provisions of this subdivision (b)(1)(E) shall not be construed
to require the disclosure of a trade secret or proprietary information
held or used by an association or nonprofit corporation to which this
chapter applies. In the event a trade secret or proprietary information
is required to be discussed in an open meeting, the association or nonprofit
corporation may conduct an executive session to discuss such trade secret
or proprietary information; provided, that a notice of the executive session
is included in the agenda for such meeting.
(iii) As used in this subdivision (b)(1)(E):
(a) “Proprietary information” means rating information, plans,
or proposals; actuarial information; specifications for specific services
provided; and any other similar commercial or financial information used
in making or deliberating toward a decision by employees, agents or the
board of directors of such association or corporation; and which if known
to a person or entity outside the association or corporation would give
such person or entity an advantage or an opportunity to gain an advantage
over the association or corporation when providing or bidding to provide
the same or similar services to local governments; and
(b) “Trade secret” means the whole or any portion or phrase
of any scientific or technical information, design, process, procedure,
formula or improvement which is secret and of value. The trier of fact
may infer a trade secret to be secret when the owner thereof takes measures
to prevent it from becoming available to persons other than those selected
by the owner to have access thereto for limited purposes;
(2) “Meeting” means the convening of a governing body of a
public body for which a quorum is required in order to make a decision
or to deliberate toward a decision on any matter. “Meeting”
does not include any on-site inspection of any project or program.
(c) Nothing in this section shall be construed as to require a chance
meeting of two (2) or more members of a public body to be considered a
public meeting. No such chance meetings, informal assemblages, or electronic
communication shall be used to decide or deliberate public business in
circumvention of the spirit or requirements of this part.
[Acts 1974, ch. 442, § 2; 1979, ch. 411, §§ 1, 2; T.C.A.,
§ 8-4402; Acts 1985, ch. 290, § 1, 2; 1986, ch. 594, §
1; 1988, ch. 908, §§ 3, 5; 1997, ch. 346, § 1; 1998, ch.
1102, §§ 1, 3.]
8-44-103. Notice of public meetings. — (a) Notice of Regular Meetings.
Any such governmental body which holds a meeting previously scheduled
by statute, ordinance, or resolution shall give adequate public notice
of such meeting.
(b) Notice of Special Meetings. Any such governmental body which holds
a meeting not previously scheduled by statute, ordinance, or resolution,
or for which notice is not already provided by law, shall give adequate
public notice of such meeting.
(c) The notice requirements of this part are in addition to, and not in
substitution of, any other notice required by law.
[Acts 1974, ch. 442, § 3; T.C.A., § 8-4403.]
8-44-104. Minutes recorded and open to public — Secret votes prohibited.
— (a) The minutes of a meeting of any such governmental body shall
be promptly and fully recorded, shall be open to public inspection, and
shall include, but not be limited to, a record of persons present, all
motions, proposals and resolutions offered, the results of any votes taken,
and a record of individual votes in the event of roll call.
(b) All votes of any such governmental body shall be by public vote or
public ballot or public roll call. No secret votes, or secret ballots,
or secret roll calls shall be allowed. As used in this chapter, “public
vote” means a vote in which the “aye” faction vocally
expresses its will in unison and in which the “nay” faction,
subsequently, vocally expresses its will in unison.
[Acts 1974, ch. 442, § 4; T.C.A., § 8-4404; Acts 1980, ch. 800,
§ 1.]
8-44-105. Action nullified - Exception. — Any action taken at a
meeting in violation of this part shall be void and of no effect; provided,
that this nullification of actions taken at such meetings shall not apply
to any commitment, otherwise legal, affecting the public debt of the entity
concerned.
[Acts 1974, ch. 442, § 5; T.C.A., § 8-4405.]
8-44-106. Enforcement - Jurisdiction. — (a) The circuit courts,
chancery courts, and other courts which have equity jurisdiction, have
jurisdiction to issue injunctions, impose penalties, and otherwise enforce
the purposes of this part upon application of any citizen of this state.
(b) In each suit brought under this part, the court shall file written
findings of fact and conclusions of law and final judgments, which shall
also be recorded in the minutes of the body involved.
(c) The court shall permanently enjoin any person adjudged by it in violation
of this part from further violation of this part. Each separate occurrence
of such meetings not held in accordance with this part constitutes a separate
violation.
(d) The final judgment or decree in each suit shall state that the court
retains jurisdiction over the parties and subject matter for a period
of one (1) year from date of entry, and the court shall order the defendants
to report in writing semiannually to the court of their compliance with
this part.
[Acts 1974, ch. 442, § 6; T.C.A., § 8-4406.]
8-44-107. Board of directors of Performing Arts Center Management Corporation.
— The board of directors of the Tennessee Performing Arts Center
Management Corporation shall be subject to, and shall in all respects
comply with, all of the provisions made applicable to governing bodies
by this chapter. [Acts 1981, ch. 375, § 1.]
8-44-108. Participation by electronic or other means. — (a) As used
in this section, unless the context otherwise requires:
(1) “Governing body” refers only to boards, agencies and commissions
of state government, including state debt issuers as defined in this section;
(2) “Meeting” has the same definition as defined in §
8-44-102;
(3) “Necessity” means that the matters to be considered by
the governing body at that meeting require timely action by the body,
that physical presence by a quorum of the members is not practical within
the period of time requiring action, and that participation by a quorum
of the members by electronic or other means of communication is necessary;
and
(4) “State debt issuers” means the Tennessee state funding
board, Tennessee local development authority, Tennessee housing development
agency, and Tennessee state school bond authority, and any of their committees.
(b) (1) A governing body may, but is not required to, allow participation
by electronic or other means of communication for the benefit of the public
and the governing body in connection with any meeting authorized by law;
provided, that a physical quorum is present at the location specified
in the notice of the meeting as the location of the meeting.
(2) If a physical quorum is not present at the location of a meeting of
a governing body, then in order for a quorum of members to participate
by electronic or other means of communication, the governing body must
make a determination that a necessity exists. Such determination, and
a recitation of the facts and circumstances on which it was based, must
be included in the minutes of the meeting.
(3) If a physical quorum is not present at the location of a meeting of
a governing body other than a state debt issuer, the governing body other
than a state debt issuer must file such determination of necessity, including
the recitation of the facts and circumstances on which it was based, with
the office of secretary of state no later than two (2) working days after
the meeting. The secretary of state shall report, no less than annually,
to the general assembly as to the filings of the determinations of necessity.
(c)(1) Any meeting held pursuant to the terms of this section shall comply
with the requirements of the Open Meetings Law, codified in this part,
and shall not circumvent the spirit or requirements of that law.
(2) Notices required by the Open Meetings Law, or any other notice required
by law, shall state that the meeting will be conducted permitting participation
by electronic or other means of communication.
(3) Each part of a meeting required to be open to the public shall be
audible to the public at the location specified in the notice of the meeting
as the location of the meeting. Each member participating electronically
or otherwise must be able to simultaneously hear each other and speak
to each other during the meeting. Any member participating in such fashion
shall identify the persons present in the location from which the member
is participating.
(4) Any member of a governing body not physically present at a meeting
shall be provided, before the meeting, with any documents that will be
discussed at the meeting, with substantially the same content as those
documents actually presented.
(5) All votes taken during a meeting held pursuant to the terms of this
section shall be by roll call vote.
(6) A member participating in a meeting by this means is deemed to be
present in person at the meeting for purposes of voting, but not for purposes
of determining per diem eligibility. However, a member may be reimbursed
expenses of such electronic communication or other means of participation.
[Acts 1990, ch. 815, § 1; 1999, ch. 490, § 1.]
8-44-201. Labor negotiations between public employee union and state or
local government. —(a) Notwithstanding any other provision of Tennessee
law to the contrary, labor negotiations between representatives of public
employee unions or associations and representatives of a state or local
governmental entity shall be open to the public, whether or not the negotiations
by the state or local governmental entity are under the direction of the
legislative, executive or judicial branch of government.
(b) Nothing contained in this section shall be construed to require that
planning or strategy sessions of either the union committee or the governmental
entity committee, meeting separately, be open to the public.
(c) Nothing contained in this section shall be construed to grant recognition
rights of any sort.
(d) Both sides shall decide jointly and announce in advance of any such
labor negotiations where such meetings shall be held. [Acts 1979, ch.
41, § 1; T.C.A., § 8-4421.]
Editor’s Note: An exception was created by the Supreme Court of
Tennessee in 1984 regarding certain attorney-client communications. An
attorney may meet with a client otherwise subject to the Sunshine Law
for the purpose of discussing only present and pending litigation to which
the public body has been named. Clients may provide the attorney with
facts and information regarding the lawsuit and the attorney may advise
them of the legal ramifications of those facts. Once any discussion whatsoever
begins regarding action to be taken based upon that advice, whether settlement
or otherwise, such discussion must be open to the public. This is a narrow
exception. Smith County Educ. Ass’n v. Anderson, 676 S.W.2d 328,
334-35 (Tenn. 1984). This attorney-client privilege exception was extended
to discussions of pending controversies or potential litigation. Cooper
v. Williamson Co. Bd. of Education, 746 S.W.2d 176 (Tenn. 1987); Van Hooser
v. Warren Co. Bd. of Education, 807 S.W.2d 230 (Tenn. 1991).
SHIELD LAW
T.C.A. § 24-1-208
24-1-208. Persons gathering information for publication or broadcast -
Disclosure.— (a) A person engaged in gathering information for publication
or broadcast connected with or employed by the news media or press, or
who is independently engaged in gathering information for publication
or broadcast, shall not be required by a court, a grand jury, the general
assembly, or any administrative body, to disclose before the general assembly
or any Tennessee court, grand jury, agency, department, or commission
any information or the source of any information procured for publication
or broadcast.
(b) Subsection (a) shall not apply with respect to the source of any allegedly
defamatory information in any case where the defendant in a civil action
for defamation asserts a defense based on the source of such information.
(c)(1) Any person seeking information or the source thereof protected
under this section may apply for an order divesting such protection. Such
application shall be made to the judge of the court having jurisdiction
over the hearing, action or other proceeding in which the information
sought is pending.
(2) The application shall be granted only if the court after hearing the
parties determines that the person seeking the information has shown by
clear and convincing evidence that:
(A) There is probable cause to believe that the person from whom the information
is sought has information which is clearly relevant to a specific probable
violation of law;
(B) The person has demonstrated that the information sought cannot reasonably
be obtained by alternative means; and
(C) The person has demonstrated a compelling and overriding public interest
of the people of the state of Tennessee in the information.
(3(A) Any order of the trial court may be appealed to the court of appeals
in the same manner as other civil cases. The court of appeals shall make
an independent determination of the applicability of the standards in
this subsection to the facts in the record and shall not accord a presumption
of correctness to the trial court’s findings.
(B) The execution of or any proceeding to enforce a judgment divesting
the protection of this section shall be stayed pending appeal upon the
timely filing of a notice of appeal in accordance with Rule 3 of the Tennessee
Rules of Appellate Procedure, and the appeal shall be expedited upon the
docket of the court of appeals upon the application of either party.
(C) Any order of the court of appeals may be appealed to the supreme court
of Tennessee as provided by law. [Acts 1973, ch. 27, §§ 1-3;
T.C.A, § 24-113 - 24-115; Acts 1988, ch. 803, §§ 1, 2.]
Editor’s Note: The Shield protection granted by T.C.A. §24-1-208
applies even in a civil case where information has been previously published
and the information or source of information was not obtained as a result
of a confidential relationship. Austin v. Memphis Publishing Co., 655
S.W.2d 146 (Tenn. 1983).
|
|